Dave Fox

A Long-Standing Debate

Raising the Seat to its Upright and Locked Position

 

By Dave Fox

I walked into the bathroom at work recently and found a sign on the wall. "Men," it said, "please put the seat down after use."

The debate about a man's moral obligation to leave the toilet seat down has been raging since prehistoric times. Years ago, I asked my girlfriend what the big deal was.

"A lady should never have to touch a toilet seat," she told me.

Our relationship ended shortly thereafter.

Call me a bleeding-heart liberal commie if you must, but I don't agree with the notion that women are so feeble, they will develop a life-threatening twitch if they come in contact with a toilet seat. On the contrary, I feel a thank you is in order for the fact that we men put the seat up in the first place.

This is a sensitive issue, I realize. I could end up single for the rest of my life for writing this. But it's the 21st century, and if we're going to have sexual equality, I don't believe we should have a double standard in the bathroom.

I have come up with a gender-neutral solution to the problem. On odd-numbered days of the month, everybody puts the seat down. On even-numbered days, we put it up.

If you don't like that idea, here's another: Let's all switch to the hole-in-the-floor-style toilets that are prevalent in other parts of the world. In a public restroom, it's a lot more sanitary to hover over a hole in the floor than it is to sit in the same spot where thousands of strangers have sat before you. Squatting is also good exercise.

Americans condescendingly refer to these toilets as "Turkish toilets." I'm not sure how Turkey got pegged as the patent owner for this style of commode. They're found in many countries. Of all the wonderful cultural things Turkey has to offer, we name a toilet after them? But national identities aside, I realize this plan won't fly in the US. Americans have a severe dread of squat toilets.

When President Bush (the elder) visited Turkey during his time in office, the Turkish government gave him the plushest accommodations in all of Istanbul — a room right inside the legendary Topkapi Palace. There was just one problem. There was no sit-down toilet. Turkish officials ordered a brand new westernized one so the president wouldn't have to squat.

Who knows? Perhaps world leaders do their best thinking while seated. But I can't help believing we would have a more peaceful world if we had gender-neutral toilets.

A man's ability to aim is another source of conflict. The problem is bad enough that one hotel in Denmark actually has a sign in the restroom with detailed instructions.

"It has been brought to the attention of Det Lille Hotel," the sign reads, "that fairly basic water drainage is clearly a problem for many men…."

The sign offers a 12-step plan for on-target urination. Among the advice offered:

  • Point 4: "If you are not able to see your water drainage device due to your stomach, then pull your trousers down completely and be seated."

  • Point 5: "If you really can see your water drainage device, then take one more step forward. It's not as long as you think."

  • Point 11: "If you are not able to follow these instructions, it is requested that you avoid using the toilet."

I agree that men need to be more conscientious. Granted, after a couple of beers, the target gets harder to hit, but wiping up our splashes is the polite thing to do.

What I find equally troubling, however, is reports from my female spy friends who have broken their code of silence and revealed to me part of what goes on in the ladies' room. Reliable female sources tell me that in public restrooms, many women don't sit down. They hover. The same female sources tell me women miss more than men, and they don't bother to put the seat up first.

In an attempt to remedy this situation, a nurse named Denise Becker has launched a website instructing women how to stand. "No more hovering over filthy toilets or getting poison ivy on your bum!" the site promises.

This is a serious website intended for mature adults, which is why I did not read it very carefully. But if you are curious and you promise not to giggle at Nurse Decker's very serious campaign, you will find her site at www.restrooms.org.

Men and women have entirely different cultures when it comes to bathroom etiquette. For example, I don't get why women like to go to the bathroom together when they're out in public. I would lose most of my male friends if I asked them to come with me.

As for my own personal restroom behavior, I have always followed the advice of my mother. She taught me to always close the lid completely.


Davethefox.com is extremely concerned that all sides are represented in this emotional issue. Replies to this column have been posted on the April 2002 Outbursts page.

 
© Copyright Dave Fox